If I had a dollar for every time I hear something about Gen Y or get a jibe for being ‘one’ I would be a very rich woman, and not need to work another day in my life. This is fitting because according to most of the myths around Gen Y we don’t want to work, move out of home or spend any time in the grunt jobs because world domination is just around the corner.
The misconceptions that Gen Y are different and need to be managed differently have fuelled an entire industry and lined the pockets of many industrious trainers.
According to a recent article in HR Monthly, Gen Y is:
1982–1995
- Easily bored, prone to job changing for more satisfaction, stimulation or money
- Highly educated and ambitious
- Very prepared to share their opinions on nearly everything
- Technology is a part of what they do
Well, there you go, I’ve at least saved you $200 on a seminar because you can find out what we’re about from those few dot points which surely sum up an entire generation of people from various countries, socio-economic levels and who have of course had the same life experiences (perhaps, they should include highly sarcastic as well).
Is it simply not that as technology and society has changed we have grown with it? Just as past generations would have moved from written correspondence to typewriters the current generations have moved to a more computer savvy environment.
During this time there have also been changes in business and how business is done, there has been a greater focus on what business gives back and green businesses have started to gain more recognition.
People are spending absurd amounts of money to find out what it takes to manage Gen Y, well here’s the secret, if you are a good manager you won’t have any problems.
Here are the basics (of management - nothing to do with generations):
- Talk to your employees, find out what they want, don’t assume because one thing works with one person that will work with everyone
- Support them, if you know what your employees want in a role help them to get there
- Provide constructive feedback at appropriate times, this means timely (ie. not during a once yearly performance review & not in front of other people)
- Ask, if people are unhappy or you notice that someone starts acting differently, ask don’t assume
- Find out how people learn, visual, by doing, by reading and make sure that training fits with this
- Don’t box your employees, by personality type, generation or any other generalisation, it is alienating
- Give people valuable meaningful work to do, it doesn't have to be 100% of the work, but at least some of it
Grouping people into a generation and using stereotypes to determine how you manage people is lazy, not everyone will fit into a box or fit the model.
Employees are individuals, if you manage them like this, what generation someone is doesn't matter.

Couldnt't agree more. The whole Gen Y focus is a total joke. I to am;
ReplyDelete- Easily bored, prone to job changing for more satisfaction, stimulation or money
- Highly educated and ambitious
- Very prepared to share their opinions on nearly everything
- Technology is a part of what they do
And I am not Gen Y. I have heard that Gen Y want a challenging job, well so do I, I have heard that Gen Y want a work life balance, well so do I.
The Gen Y focus is a farce, we are all after the same thing, secure job, work life balance, decent money so we can live and enjoy ourselves, and a company that looks after their employees.
We are all human, we are all seeking the same happiness of life, some to varying degrees, but to claim a whole generation needs to be dealt with differently, and that they are "special" is quite simply laughable.
I have also blogged on this topic http://socialrecruiting360.com/2009/11/25/dont-get-caught-in-the-trap/
Exactly, my Dad wants the same things in life that I do, he probably has more patience than me but when it comes down to it all the things you've mentioned are what most people want in their jobs.
ReplyDeleteJust had a read of your post, seems we've been thinking the same things!
Your sentiments posted here are both congruent and contrary to some of the points on my blog. First and foremost I think your thoughts are completely accurate in that there is definitely a "Management" problem in HR revolving around the new workforce, not a "generational" problem. I am actually going to use and link to this post in my next blog post as a point-counter point example.
ReplyDeleteI am contrary to you in that I don't think it is wholly a management problem. I recently commented that boomers cannot seriously expect GEN Y to be anything less given that we were raised (by the boomers I might add) to feel special, to think special, and to feel that we should be rewarded just for showing up. This says to me there is something more than just poor HR management at play here. Is it social? Is it personal? Who is to say, but I feel it is a problem bigger than even HR can address effectively.
That said I completely agree is that not all Gen Y fits into this box. I mean I was born in late 81 so I consider myself to be a "cusper" Millennial. However my parents are early-and-cusper Boomers. My sisters are both decidedly GEN X, with disco 70's birthdays. I possess many of the traits above, but I also possess a lot EQ thanks to my multi-generational upbringing. I think that is the future of HR... not the touchy feel side of EQ, but the understanding your place in the world side. That and bringing HR strategy to the forefront... but that is another convo entirely!
Great post, already retweeted once, will retweet and FB link this on my blog's FB site.
Cheers
Five Tips to Successfully Retain Generation Y Managers
ReplyDeletehttp://www.whatdoyouwantfromthem.com/?retain_managers
As a Gen Xer who teaches classes on leadership/management, I'm happy to see an honest and insightful post on the generational myth. Now if only companies would stop requesting them in the programs I teach.
ReplyDeleteHooray for saying it like it is: lazy slobs are NOT from one generation. There are a whole lot of lazy-ass Baby Boomers too.
ReplyDeleteGood people are good people and they usually engage themselves in their work in proportion to how the manager (immediate first-line supervisor) takes an interest in them.
Well said.
Kevin Burns - Management Attitude/Culture Strategist
http://www.kevburns.com
Anna clearly you haven't read the post or you'd realise it was the opposite, there are no secrets!
ReplyDeletePerhaps as Asaad has noted the issue is not just management skills, but people being able to evolve and see that changes aren't just generational.
Thanks everyone for all your thoughts and links, I really appreciate it
Ellison, First of all as a Gen Y, I would like to thank you for clearing the air with this blog.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your points on management. In my recent blog post "Gen X or Gen Y" - Deliver Value. I have mentioned that its nothing to do with generations, groups etc. It's all about Individuals, Performance, Focus. No matter which generation we are, we need to deliver value and thats the big differentiator.
You can read my complete blog post here http://ow.ly/20aSf and I would love to know your thoughts on it.
Kapil
@kapilpoojari